Sunday, July 22, 2012

Removing the Paterno Statue--Statement of President Erickson

In this country, at this university and at this time, symbols appear to have become far more important than substance.  Intangibles--values, governance, conduct--are too difficult to grasp and much too complex to afford the momentary satisfaction of action-fulfillment.  And thus it is that the Penn State community and its spectators have focused almost unrelentingly on the issue of a piece of statuary that currently (but not for long) sits next to the Penn State football stadium.  The statue has been transfigured from a piece of metal-work in the image of a coach recently deceased to what to some may well be the incarnation of university itself.  Sad, but hardly unusual in these times.  But what to do?

 (Pix from Tina Hay, About the Paterno Statue, The Penn Stater, July 17, 2012)

A number  of solutions might have been considered.  The statue could have remained unmolested; it could have been modified to add additional statuary or commentary (perhaps an additional memorial) to remind one that the message of the image might be more complex; it could have been moved, perhaps to a sports museum and used as part of a teaching moment about the strengths and weaknesses of humans, their capacity for greatness and their propensity to err; it could have been melted and turned into medals or other objects for sale to the faithful; it could have been stored in the way that family embarrassments were once hidden from view in the early 20th century  (recall the family circumstances in Kafka's Metamorphosis); it could have been removed pending a determination of final disposition. 

The University President has made his decision on the matter.  President Erickson also expressed views about the removal of the Paterno name from the library, something that might also be further discussed in the future. The University Faculty Senate played no role in either decision. As an individual, I respect these choices and present President Erickson's announcement here without  comment.

Statement by Penn State President Rodney Erickson related to Joe Paterno Statue

Since we learned of the Grand Jury presentment and the charges against Jerry Sandusky and University officials last November, members of the Penn State community and the public have been made much more acutely aware of the tragedy of child sexual abuse. Our thoughts and prayers continue to go out to those victims of Mr. Sandusky and all other victims of child abuse. I assure you that Penn State will take a national leadership role in the detection and prevention of child maltreatment in the months and years ahead.

With the release of Judge Freeh's Report of the Special Investigative Counsel, we as a community have had to confront a failure of leadership at many levels. The statue of Joe Paterno outside Beaver Stadium has become a lightning rod of controversy and national debate, including the role of big time sports in university life. The Freeh Report has given us a great deal to reflect upon and to consider, including Coach Paterno's legacy.

Throughout Penn State, the two most visible memorials to Coach Paterno are the statue at Beaver Stadium and the Paterno Library. The future of these two landmarks has been the topic of heated debate and many messages have been received in various University offices, including my own. We have heard from numerous segments of the Penn State community and others, many of whom have differing opinions. These are particularly important decisions when considering things that memorialize such a revered figure.

I now believe that, contrary to its original intention, Coach Paterno's statue has become a source of division and an obstacle to healing in our University and beyond. For that reason, I have decided that it is in the best interest of our university and public safety to remove the statue and store it in a secure location. I believe that, were it to remain, the statue will be a recurring wound to the multitude of individuals across the nation and beyond who have been the victims of child abuse.

On the other hand, the Paterno Library symbolizes the substantial and lasting contributions to the academic life and educational excellence that the Paterno family has made to Penn State University. The library remains a tribute to Joe and Sue Paterno's commitment to Penn State's student body and academic success, and it highlights the positive impacts Coach Paterno had on the University. Thus I feel strongly that the library's name should remain unchanged.

Coach Paterno's positive impact over the years and everything he did for this University predate his statue. At the same time it is true that our institution's excellence cannot be attributed to any one person or to athletics. Rather, Penn State is defined by our actions and accomplishments as a learning community. Penn State has long been an outstanding academic institution and we will continue to be.

The world will be watching how Penn State addresses its challenges in the days ahead. While some may take issue with the decisions I have made, I trust that everyone associated with our University will respond in a civil and respectful manner.

I fully realize that my decision will not be popular in some Penn State circles, but I am certain it is the right and principled decision. I believe we have chosen a course that both recognizes the many contributions that Joe Paterno made to the academic life of our University, while taking seriously the conclusions of the Freeh Report and the national issue of child sexual abuse. Today, as every day, our hearts go out to the victims.


  1. thats total crap paterno never sexually touched boys... how would his statue be a reminder of something that he had no part in... he did what he was supposed to do... he went to his boss... like he was supposed to do... the boss is the person that didnt do enough... not paterno... theyre just looking to put the blame on someone who isnt even alive to defend himself... he was a respected man and an idol to people worldwide... and its bad enough you took his statue away... but now your contemplating taking his name off the library... that statue was basically like a national landmark people everywhere were going to the statue so they could see that statue and get a picture standing by it...and the fact that you took it down early so no one would realize that you were doing it shows that you know that it wouldnt be easy if the public were able to have a word in the say... you guys are now oweing 60 million dollars... well the statue is what brought alot of people to your games... i say you should put the statue back up and... get all the thoughts of completely getting rid of joe paternos memories and reminders of how great of a coach he was and how much he was loved and respected... out of your heads and focus on how your going to get a coach even close to that good ever again.

  2. I don't have an opinion on what should be done with the statue, among the options above, though I cannot help but be reminded by the option of total obliteration of the process of history rewriting under totalitarian regimes, where names enter and leave the history books according to the latest purge.
    What disturbs me is the lack of deliberative process on this issue. There are many groups of stakeholders for the Paterno statue, ranging from the Paterno family down to current PSU students. I cannot see that any of them were consulted.
    Interim President Erickson promised increased transparency in his administration, and the Freeh report outlined how the Penn State administrative culture of tight-lipped decision-making by just a handful of insiders helped create the present situation, and that this culture must be changed for Penn State to progress. Yet here we are, back to arbitrary, top-down decision-making.